If Reason and Compromise don’t Work, how about Music? Civil War could be a bad Alternative.

Music and verse have long encouraged churches, nations and others.
Perhaps it’s time to try that again.

Yesterday, I posted this piece because it provided a brief respite from the horrors of what now passes for civilization. It includes two YouTube videos of “flash mobs” doing their bit for good and a rendition of The Impossible Dream. Descending from my cloud of euphoria, I began to wonder whether music and verse might inspire us to understand what we need to do before it becomes too late.

During the years of Irish Rebellion, songs of revolution inspired many. During the War between the States, songs on both sides did the same. Neither side might have fought as well as they did without them. When I was in college, a history teacher commented that the horse cavalry had provided an element of class to what would otherwise have been dreary battles. Was he right? I think he was, but the horse cavalry has been relegated to purely ceremonial functions, generally involving funerals.

How about some new songs of rebellion, this time against the ever increasing national debt and distribution of pork and other free stuff, ObamaCare, vote fraud, political correctness and coverups? How about some urging the importance of the rights of States and of their citizens to release themselves from the tyranny of excessive Federal meddling? How about some urging the critical importance of freedom of speech?

I am not a poet and were I to try to sing anyone foolish enough even to begin to listen would run away, hands over ears.  So, the best I can do is try to provide a few suggestions. Maybe, should there be a demand, poets and musicians will come up with the necessary songs of inspiration.

Music of the Church

The Christian Church has long used music to inspire. Many composers and musicians were long employed for that purpose and some still are.  Would Bach, Beethoven, Brahms and others have produced the beautiful music they did without such support? Remember Handel’s Messiah? Beautiful music, and when the Hallelujah Chorus is played believers and non-believers alike are inspired to stand.  Few can resist the inspiration of such music.

War would be dreadful and should be avoided at any almost any cost except when that leads ultimately to even more bloody wars or worse. That happened in Europe in the 1930s; World War II, which could with relative ease have been avoided, resulted — against far more powerful enemies than in the mid 1030s.

We have become accustomed to referring to many actions so different from war in the traditional sense that they are nonsensical; we have wars on drugs, wars on AIDS, wars on poverty, wars on obesity and now a (Republican) war on women (according to Democrats). No musical symbolism of actual war accompanies those spurious wars. Perhaps, however, if we are to engage successfully in a “war” on governmental tyranny some of the symbolism of actual war is appropriate.

Music from the War of Northern Aggression War Between the States.

I wrote in The U.S. Constitution and Civil War that the war was fought by the South to preserve the rights of the States and by the North to reunify the nation by force.

According to the National Endowment for the Humanities,

While the Civil War began as a war to restore the Union, not to end slavery, by 1862 President Abraham Lincoln came to believe that he could save the Union only by broadening the goals of the war. The Emancipation Proclamation [of 1864] is generally regarded as marking this sharp change in the goals of Lincoln’s war policy. (Insert added)

I understand that as the history of the war is now generally taught, States’ Rights had nothing to do with it and the elimination of slavery was the sole issue. That was not the case. Did the Union begin to sense only in 1862 that the idea of rooting out slavery in the South had to be claimed as the cause because of the inspiration it could provide? I don’t know. Be that as it may, many in the United States view the war “to preserve slavery” as a horrid disgrace to the South. It was not and was far from that.

That is also coming to be case with the origins of the nation as a whole.

[A]cademia’s systemic hatred for America’s cultural traditions and her Judeo-Christian heritage is reaching a fevered pitch. The volume in the echo chamber created by academia, big government, and the mainstream media grows with each election cycle and each major holiday. As many Americans tend to view these opinions as alien caricatures of values which they hold dear, the kooks on the left become more and more frenzied in their effort to “fundamentally transform” America. Case in point: A recent link on the Drudge Report led to a link about an article by a professor at the University of Texas.

In this piece, the author states:

Thanksgiving is the day when the dominant white culture (and, sadly, most of the rest of the non-white but non-indigenous population) celebrates the beginning of a genocide that was, in fact, blessed by the men we hold up as our heroic founding fathers.

And further writes:

How does a country deal with the fact that some of its most revered historical figures had certain moral values and political views virtually identical to Nazis?

Of course, such shallow analysis and views aren’t all that new. Most of us realize that such views are the offspring of 1960’s radicalism. Many of those radicals now hold positions of power in academia, government and the media and their worldview is dominant – at least within those institutions. But what’s troubling is that this mindset is being foisted upon the minds of America’s youth – at all levels of our educational system and often without the knowledge of parents. For example, it was recently reported that some Texas schools are teaching students that the Boston Tea Party was an “act of terrorism.” (Emphasis in original.)

If the very origins of the United States are increasingly seen as pernicious, perhaps songs of the South might help to put other matters in better perspective as well. The Civil War is an important part of our history and we neither can nor should forgot it. Since I view the Civil War as having been fought principally to restore the rights of the States under the Constitution, and consider the rights of the States to be even more insidiously endangered today than even in the 1860s, I have selected only songs of the Confederacy. Some of their symbolism could be useful.

To Arms in Dixie

The Irish Brigade

The Battle Cry of Freedom

To Arms in Dixie (another version)

Here are some from the Irish rebellion.

The Irish rebellion was in some ways similar to the American War Between the States. The Clancy Brothers and Tommy Makem achieved popularity, as did their Irish songs, in the 1960s. The group split up but in 1984 got back together and sang for a few years. Liam Clancy, the last of the Clancy Brothers, died in 2009  and Tommy Makem died in 2007. Their songs have survived and many of their most popular songs relate to the Irish rebellions. Here are a few of my favorites:

God Bless England

In some ways, England’s “love” for the ignorant Irish reminds me of the “love” the Federal Government professes for “its people,” for whom it claims to seek only the best in keeping them on the Federal plantation.

Rising of the Moon

Dr. Johnson’s Motor Car

Here’s one from World War I.

That was a bloody war, with many needless deaths.

Over There

Here’s one from World War II.

Bless them all

That was also a needless war that should have been prevented in proactive fashion during the 1930s. It wasn’t, because a “peace at any price” notion commonly prevailed. We now see much the same, not only in the United States but throughout the non-Islamist, “civilized” world. The Middle East today provides striking examples and Israel likely faces a far bloodier and otherwise worse war to come than would have resulted from her continued efforts to root out the aggressive evils of Hamas and its Islamist allies.

We do not desire a bloody war, but neither did most of the people of England in the 1930s. Some of the best and brightest of the young agreed with the now infamous Oxford Resolution of 1933, “That this House will in no circumstances fight for its King and Country.”  In The Gathering Storm, Winston Churchill wrote,

In this dark time the basest sentiments received acceptance or passed unchallenged by the responsible leaders of the political parties. In 1933, the students of the Oxford Union, under the inspiration of a Mr. Joad, passed their ever-shameful resolution, “That this House will in no circumstances fight for its King and Country.” It was easy to laugh off such an episode in England, but in Germany, in Russia, in Italy, in Japan, the idea of a decadent, degenerate Britain took deep root and swayed many calculations. Little did the foolish boys who passed the resolution dream that they were destined quite soon to conquer or fall gloriously in the ensuing war, and prove themselves the finest generation ever bred in Britain. Less excuse can be found for their elders, who had no chance of self-redemption in action.

Some of that rings true today. As freedom wanes, we have become increasingly decadent and far too many have become willingly dependent upon — and beholden to — governments for the necessities and non-necessities they provide. As the “free stuff” continues to flow unabated, many recipients (along with those who enable them) evidently see less need for the freedoms which permit the exercise of personal responsibility and even a modicum of self reliance. Since they don’t value those freedoms why should anyone else — taxed to provide them the “free stuff” they crave — cherish those freedoms? Obviously they must just be selfish jerks who hate the less fortunate who had nothing to do with causing their own misfortunes because “somebody else” did that.

Governmental ability to continue to maintain them in the style to which they have become accustomed is finite and a time will eventually come when it is no longer possible unless they are weaned off the governmental teat. What will happen when the ObamaPhones break and are not replaced, when patients who would otherwise have been treated do not receive the benefits they were promised under ObamaCare and when Electronic Benefit Transfer (EBT) cards and food stamps are drastically curtailed because there is no more ObamaMoney to provide them? Will the previously content recipients riot or worse? Can we avoid becoming another Greece? The old Grecian Formula Sixteen slogan, “a little dab will do ya,” hasn’t applied thus far and instead of a “little dab” it has been seen as shovel ready to be heaped on with abandon.

We should use the means necessary to restore and preserve freedom and also the spirit of freedom in the United States; without that spirit, freedom will die. Music lifts and enables our spirits and can also help to “make the medicine go down in a most delightful way.” We should at least try. It should be fun and might even do some good.

About danmillerinpanama

I was graduated from Yale University in 1963 with a B.A. in economics and from the University of Virginia School of law, where I was the notes editor of the Virginia Law Review in 1966. Following four years of active duty with the Army JAG Corps, with two tours in Korea, I entered private practice in Washington, D.C. specializing in communications law. I retired in 1996 to sail with my wife, Jeanie, on our sailboat Namaste to and in the Caribbean. In 2002, we settled in the Republic of Panama and live in a very rural area up in the mountains. I have contributed to Pajamas Media and Pajamas Tatler. In addition to my own blog, Dan Miller in Panama, I an an editor of Warsclerotic and contribute to China Daily Mail when I have something to write about North Korea.
This entry was posted in 2016 Obama's America, Abuse of Power, Appeasement, Belief, Chamberlain, Christians, Conservatives, Constitution, Cultural differences, Democrats, Dignity, Economics, Elections, England, Food stamps, Formerly Great Britain, free speech, Freedom, Good stuff for everone free, Government and individual choices, Government reliance, Greece, Health Control, History, Islamist rage, Israel, Law and Order, Limitation on Authority, ObamaCare, Obamaphone, Political Correctness, Politics, Religion, Socialism, States' Rights, Thanksgiving, United States, War on women and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to If Reason and Compromise don’t Work, how about Music? Civil War could be a bad Alternative.

  1. Pingback: When things keep going wrong We should change how We deal with them | danmillerinpanama

  2. Pingback: Are Democratically Elected Dictators Hostile to Freedom “Good” Dictators? | danmillerinpanama

  3. Pingback: Opinion Forum » What’s a Conservative to Do?

  4. Pingback: What’s a Conservative to Do? | danmillerinpanama

  5. Music is supposed to sooth the savage beast, right?

    Nice thought, Dan. Have you ever listened to the music Obama likes? Enough said.

  6. bunkerville says:

    This of course might occur if we are still allowed to sing. I wouldn’t count on it. Great vid.

  7. geneb527 says:

    Take a look at this video and I think you will agree that this is the way our next candidate should talk. That is if we ever have another candidate? http://tinyurl.com/azd7y66

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s